הסיבה שניתנה היא:These photos were taken in the 1950s in France in photo studios (mostly Harcourt), but there is not evidence that they were created / published on the year the description claims it was. Any photo published in 1954 or later is currently not in the French public domain (there are several in this DR), and any photo published in the 1950s that was not simultaneously published in the US is still copyrighted in the US. That the uploader invents the dates seems to be evident. For example, Commons:Deletion requests/File:PierreRepp-1953.png is the cover of an EP published in 1955 and it was stated in the source link. The source link of Commons:Deletion requests/File:MarinaVlady-1952-Harcourt.png clearly states the photo was taken in 1955. Some of the files in this DR give also good evidence made up dates.File:CatherineLangeais-1954.png the back states the postcard was issued for an event on September 5, 1968. File:MaryMarquet-1953-Harcourt.png mentions the year 1965 on the back. File:Denys-deLaPatelliere-1951-Harcourt.png is from a eBay item that sells photos from 1955 until 1971. File:Caccia-Harcourt-1950-Harcourt.jpg is from an eBay item that says it was taken in the 1960s. File:JeanRichard-1953-Harcourt.png actually states it was taken 1949 (not included on this DR as it states when it was published).
All in all, there is no evidence that the date of publication are correct, the claimed ones make them either copyrighted in France or close to the limit, and there is no evidence they are in the public domain in the US even assuming the dates are correct. Following, COM:EVID and COM:PCP we cannot keep them.
{{subst:delete2|image=Files uploaded by Tisourcier|reason=These photos were taken in the 1950s in France in photo studios (mostly Harcourt), but there is not evidence that they were created / published on the year the description claims it was. Any photo published in 1954 or later is currently not in the French public domain (there are several in this DR), and any photo published in the 1950s that was not simultaneously published in the US is still copyrighted in the US. That the uploader invents the dates seems to be evident. For example, Commons:Deletion requests/File:PierreRepp-1953.png is the cover of an EP published in 1955 and it was stated in the source link. The source link of Commons:Deletion requests/File:MarinaVlady-1952-Harcourt.png clearly states the photo was taken in 1955. Some of the files in this DR give also good evidence made up dates.
All in all, there is no evidence that the date of publication are correct, the claimed ones make them either copyrighted in France or close to the limit, and there is no evidence they are in the public domain in the US even assuming the dates are correct. Following, COM:EVID and COM:PCP we cannot keep them. --~~~~}}
Français : Jacques Morel pose légèrement penché en avant et sur sa gauche tout en orientant son visage légèrement vers sa droite, regardant en coin vers sa droite, sans émotion particulière. Il porte les cheveux courts, noirs, brillants et coiffés en arrière. Il est vêtu d'une veste noire, d'une chemise claire et d'une cravate noire.
Studio Harcourt photos have been judged to be collective works [1]
זוהי תמונה מרוטשת, זאת אומרת שהתמונה שונתה בצורה דיגיטלית מהמקור. Modifications: désaturation, gamma, densité, détails, dépoussiérage, suppression d'artefacts.
רישיון
Public domainPublic domainfalsefalse
This work is in the public domain in France for one of the following reasons:
Its author (or the last of its authors in the case of a collaboration work) died more than 70 years ago (CPI art. L123-1) and did not benefit from any copyright extension (CPI art. L123-8, L123-9 and L123-10)[1];
It is an anonymous or pseudonymous work (the identity of the author has never been disclosed) or a collective work[2] and more than 70 years have passed since its publication (CPI art. L123-3);
It is the recording of an audiovisual or musical work already in the public domain, and more than 50 years have passed since the performance or the recording (CPI art. L211-4).
Please note that moral rights still apply when the work is in the public domain. They encompass, among others, the right to the respect of the author's name, quality and work (CPI art. L121-1). Attribution therefore remains mandatory.
↑Copyright extensions must be considered only in the case of musical works and of authors Mort pour la France (died during conflict, in the service of France). In other cases, they are included in the 70 years post mortem auctoris length (see this statement of the Cour de Cassation).
↑The collective work status is quite restrictive, please make sure that it is actually established.