שיחה:נוית בראל

נימוק לביטולים

שלום @Chajara,
ביצעת שורת ביטולי עריכות, ללא כל נימוק בתקציר העריכה.
אני מבקש את הסבריך. – מקף ෴‏ 22:43, 12 בספטמבר 2023 (IDT)

Hello מקף

I am not yet to be familiar with changes summary

I deleted vandalism

There were many omittings lately Chajara - שיחה 11:46, 13 בספטמבר 2023 (IDT)

@Chajara: The omissions were all justified as complying with the policy of preventing advertising, and not vandalism.
Can you comment on why you think the removed content is non-advertising? – מקף ෴‏ 11:53, 13 בספטמבר 2023 (IDT)

Hello מקף

.The list of books should not be considered as advertising

.It is customary content of an entry for a literary editor

Same goes for summary of published criticism for a published book.

This content is standard in entries of colleagues. Chajara - שיחה 12:08, 13 בספטמבר 2023 (IDT)

Everything should come in a reasonable dose, the excessive detail and listing aren't such. The Hebrew Wikipedia is perhaps more careful, much more, than the English Wikipedia. If you had read the policy page I linked to you would have seen that there are even explicit prohibitions. For example, the quotes are prohibited in §4. – מקף ෴‏ 12:57, 13 בספטמבר 2023 (IDT)